Four gaps in a mill’s audit year: counts, samples, repeats, files
Audit work leaves its own records: the count sheet, the findings tracker, the working-paper file. When they are slow to read, the cost is stock nobody can explain, a weakness the Audit Committee sees twice, or a question the file cannot answer.
Stock that is on the books but not in the store
Yarn, fabric, dyes and trims pass through stores, cutting, job workers and the scrap yard. The surprise count is quick; explaining it is slow. Each variance has to be matched to issue slips, wastage records and job-work challans, and someone has to chase the stores manager for answers. For a bonded exporter, a gap between the bond register and the floor can become a customs case.
Tk269.48 crore
Customs’ preliminary estimate of alleged duty and tax evasion at six bonded textile companies in Bangladesh, after October 2026 raids found stocks that differed from their registers. It may change when the probe ends.
Source: The Financial Express (Bangladesh), Six textile companies face probe over alleged Tk269cr duty evasion (opens in a new tab), 2026.
A sample covers a slice of the year
A small audit team tests a sample of POs, GRNs, wastage approvals and scrap sales. What sits outside the sample goes unread, and reading inside it is slow: the SOP, the delegation of authority, last year’s working papers, the vendor file. The playbook’s own heuristic is that sampling misses systemic issues, and the Audit Committee relies on work that saw part of the year.
14%
Share of fraud cases in Southern Asia first found by internal audit, against 50% by a tip, though 95% of the victim organisations had an audit department. ACFE 2026: 145 cases, mostly India, all industries.
Source: Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE), Occupational Fraud 2026: A Report to the Nations (opens in a new tab), 2026.
Control gaps that stay open and return at the next audit
Each finding needs a management response, an owner and a date. Follow-up lives in an Excel tracker and email threads, and replies come late or undated. The classic repeat is segregation in purchase and stores: the same clerk raises the PO and receives the GRN, nobody checks, and the finding returns next year. The playbook treats a repeat as a management problem for the Audit Committee.
41.4%
Share of 99 Pakistani textile firms, surveyed in 2025, that said their purchasing function was not properly segregated. Every firm said it had an internal audit function.
Source: Audit and Accounting Review (University of Management and Technology, Lahore), Fraud Risk Management Practices in Emerging Markets: Empirical Evidence from Pakistan’s Textile Sector (opens in a new tab), 2026.
The working-paper file nobody can search when the committee asks
Each engagement leaves a file: scope letter, control matrix, sample, tests and conclusion. When the committee asks what was tested on purchase, someone rebuilds it; if the auditor has left, the reasoning has gone. India’s Companies Act (s.138) makes listed companies, and larger unlisted and private ones, appoint an internal auditor; Bangladesh’s 2018 BSEC code has the Audit Committee review the function.
From count sheet to committee pack: what the audit agent does
It works from the papers, registers, count sheets and stock reports uploaded to Internal Audit, and counts from their rows. Each email, sheet update or message it drafts waits for an admin to approve or decline; it runs only if approved.
A full year’s register counted, not just the sample
Answers with sources
Export a year of scrap sales, write-offs or POs as one Excel or CSV file, up to 5,000 rows, and upload it to Internal Audit. The agent counts or sums across every row, filtered on up to three exact values in your columns: the kilos sold to one buyer, the write-offs one approver signed, the POs to one vendor. Each figure cites the rows it came from. It does not choose your sample or join two files.
Ask“From the scrap sales register for the year, total the kilos sold to Karim Waste Traders on sales the stores manager approved.”
What a working paper recorded, quoted from the paper
Reads your documents
Upload the working papers, the control matrix, past audit reports and the SOPs to Internal Audit. Ask what an audit tested and the agent quotes the scope, sample, tests and conclusion as recorded, naming each file. For a listed group, ask which key controls in the ICFR matrix failed this quarter, and it lists them with the exceptions the test sheets record. Where the papers are silent, it says so.
Ask“Which controls in the purchase control matrix tested ineffective last cycle, and what exceptions did the working papers record?”
The book side of a stock check, from the system stock report
Answers with sources
Export the system stock report for the counted bins as Excel or CSV, with book and counted quantity, and shortage and excess as quantity and as value, each in its own column, and upload it to Internal Audit. The agent sums the shortage or excess for a named bin or item and counts the lines your sheet marks for a deep-dive, citing the rows. It never joins two files, and the stock record is left for Stores to correct.
Ask“From the stock report for today’s count, total the shortage value for 30s combed yarn.”
The audit summary and the committee pack, built from the papers
Creates files
Ask for an engagement summary and the agent builds it as a document from the working papers, findings ordered by recorded severity. For the quarterly committee pack, it counts plan progress from the uploaded audit plan, and open findings and repeats from the tracker; the repeat rate is repeats over all findings. Every count cites its rows. Ask for one section to change and only that is edited; every revision is kept.
Ask“Prepare the audit summary for the scrap-sales engagement from its working papers, with findings ranked by recorded severity.”
Management responses asked for in writing, with a date
Acts in your tools
The playbook calls a finding without a management response date a wish. From the uploaded tracker, the agent names the open findings with no response or target date, citing the rows. It prepares the email to each owner, through Gmail or Outlook, or the row update if you keep the live tracker in Google Sheets. The head of audit, as department admin, approves or declines each one, and it runs only if approved.
Ask“List the open findings with no management response date and draft a request to each owner for a response by the 30th.”
A surprise count, a committee week and an investigation question
The morning after a surprise count
Internal auditor
Yesterday’s surprise count of the high-value yarn and dye bins is typed up and uploaded as an Excel file.
Asks
“From yesterday’s count sheet, total the shortage value, and draft a request to the stores manager to explain the lines marked for a deep-dive by Thursday.”
The agent
Reads the count sheet: book and counted quantity, shortage and excess quantity, shortage value and excess value in separate columns, and a deep-dive column on each line. Sums the shortage value column from the rows, so excesses do not net it off, and reads the lines marked for a deep-dive, citing them. Builds the explanation schedule as a spreadsheet and prepares an Outlook email to the stores manager with those lines.
Approval
The email waits for the head of internal audit, as department admin, who approves or declines it. It is sent only if approved; declined, nothing goes out. The audit trail records who decided.
Result
A variance schedule tied to the count sheet’s rows, and a request for explanations that goes out only if approved.
A week before the Audit Committee meets
Head of internal audit
The Audit Committee meets next week and expects plan progress, open findings and the repeat rate.
Asks
“From the audit plan and the findings tracker, give me plan progress, open findings by severity and the repeat rate, and build the committee pack with each critical and high finding and its management response.”
The agent
Reads the uploaded audit plan and findings tracker. From the plan’s rows it counts engagements completed, in progress and not started; from the tracker’s, the open findings at each severity and the findings your repeat column marks, and gives the repeat rate as repeats over all findings. Every count cites its rows. Builds the pack as a document with each critical and high finding, its response and target date as recorded, naming any with no date.
Result
A committee pack where every count points to its rows, and the findings with no response date are named before the meeting.
The chair asks what an investigation found
Audit manager, investigations
The Audit Committee chair asks what last year’s investigation into scrap fabric sales concluded, before a new scrap policy goes to the board.
Asks
“What did the scrap sales investigation conclude, and on what evidence? Cite the working papers.”
The agent
Reads the investigation report and its working papers, uploaded to Internal Audit only. Quotes the conclusion as the report states it and lists the evidence each point rests on, with the working-paper reference. Where the report reaches no conclusion on a point, it says so, and it adds no allegation the report does not make.
Result
An answer for the chair that quotes the report and points to each working paper, while the file stays inside Internal Audit.
The cost of an unexplained stock gap and an open finding
These are published figures on fraud losses, fraud duration and control gaps, each cited at the source. Nothing here is a Mavick result. A pilot measures your own team: take a baseline of the plan, findings and stock-check KPIs below, then compare at the end.
Surprise checks followed through to an explanation
$74,000 vs $149,000
Median fraud loss where the victim organisation had surprise audits (any unannounced audit, not only stock counts), against where it did not, in ACFE’s 2026 global study. Only 44% had them. An association, not proof of cause.
How the agent helps
The agent does not count stock or choose the bins. When you ask, it totals the shortage value from the count sheet you upload, counts the lines your sheet marks for a deep-dive, builds the explanation schedule, and drafts the request to the stores manager for an admin to approve or decline; it runs only if approved.
Track: Surprise-check lines with variance over 2%, by quarter
Source: Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE), Occupational Fraud 2026: A Report to the Nations (opens in a new tab), 2026.
Findings closed by the date management gave
70%
Share of frauds in ACFE’s 2026 global study whose main weakness was missing internal controls (33%), an override of existing controls (19%) or no management review (18%). All industries.
How the agent helps
Upload the findings tracker and ask which findings are open: the agent counts them for a severity you name from its rows and names those with no management response date. It drafts the reminder to the owner, or the status update on that row in your Google Sheets tracker; an admin approves or declines each, and it runs only if approved. Nothing runs on a timer.
Track: Findings closed within SLA
Source: Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE), Occupational Fraud 2026: A Report to the Nations (opens in a new tab), 2026.
Exceptions read and explained while they are recent
$40,000 vs $1.1M+
Median fraud loss when a scheme was caught within six months, against schemes that ran more than five years, in ACFE’s 2026 global study of 2,402 cases. The median scheme ran 12 months before it was found. All industries.
How the agent helps
The agent finds no fraud on its own. When you ask, it counts across a full year’s export of up to 5,000 rows and answers from the working papers, naming the paper behind each answer, so more of the year is read in the hours a small team has.
Track: Audit-plan completion % against the calendar
Source: Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE), Key Findings from Occupational Fraud 2026: A Report to the Nations (opens in a new tab), 2026.
What to baseline before a pilot
Measure each one before the pilot starts, then again at its end.
| KPI to baseline | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Audit-plan completion % | It shows whether the risk-ranked plan the Audit Committee approved is being delivered. The playbook’s target is 95% or more by year-end. |
| Findings closed within SLA | The playbook targets 90% or more. Its heuristic: a finding without a management response date is a wish, so close on time-bound commitments. |
| Repeat-finding rate | The playbook targets 10% or less. A repeat means the last management response did not work, and it goes to the Audit Committee as a structural problem. |
| Surprise-check lines with variance over 2% | Each one triggers a deep-dive under the playbook’s stock-check SOP; its KPI section says to track the count and investigate the trend. |
| Critical findings reported within 7 days | Not one of the playbook’s four KPIs but its escalation rule: a critical finding goes to the CEO and the Audit Committee within 7 days, a suspected fraud to the CEO and Legal. |
What the agent works from
Records it reads
- Audit charter
- Annual audit plan
- Audit working paper
- Control matrix
- Audit report and management response
- Surprise stock-check sheet
- Fraud-investigation report
- Risk register
In your ERP
From the factory ERP, the agent reads Odoo invoices only (number, customer, total, status and date), with the fetch time, and writes nothing. Stock reports, PO and vendor exports come in as uploaded Excel or CSV; working papers, findings and the risk register as files and Google Sheets. Any other ERP gives it no records; the demo shows what yours holds.
One ERP connection serves the whole factory: SAP Business One, SAP S/4HANA, Odoo, Oracle NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, WFX Cloud ERP or Datatex NOW. This agent reads only the records named above; we check yours on the call.
In your tools
Reads an auditee’s reply in Gmail or among recent Outlook emails, or a live tracker or risk register in Google Sheets, when you ask. Prepares the request for a management response, a finding’s row update, an Outlook event for a closing meeting, or a Slack or WhatsApp Business note. An admin approves or declines each write; it runs only if approved.
Tools named today: Gmail, Outlook, Google Sheets, Slack and WhatsApp Business.
Never made up
- Audit findings, ratings or conclusions
- Control descriptions, test results or exception counts
- Variance figures from stock counts or reconciliations
- Investigation conclusions or allegations
- Residual risk ratings in the risk register
If it is not in your connected data, the agent says so.
Belongs to another department
- Running the stores process and correcting stock recordsStores & Inventory
- Raising purchase orders and managing vendorsSourcing & Procurement
- Statutory accounts and the external auditFinance & Accounts
- Certification audits and buyer social auditsCompliance & Sustainability
- Legal action arising from a findingLegal & Regulatory
What the Internal Audit & Risk playbook covers
SOP: the surprise stock check
Quarterly, by high-value bin or category. A variance above 2% triggers a deep-dive. The playbook adds that surprise checks lose their value once they are predictable, so vary both the frequency and the bins.
Decision rule: a high-severity control gap
Contain it first, suspending the process or the person if that is warranted. Then find the root cause, remediate, and check that the fix works at the next equivalent transaction. The playbook is plain about it: do not just write a report.
KPI: audit-plan completion, 95% or more by year-end
The annual plan ranks processes by inherent risk and control effectiveness, takes input from the CFO, Compliance and the plant heads, and is approved by the Audit Committee or Board. Its reporting pattern: progress every quarter, with open findings and the repeat rate.
Edge case: a finding that points at a senior manager
Confidentiality and due process, and no accusation ahead of the evidence. For a suspected fraud the order is evidence first, answers second: preserve the evidence, control who can reach it, keep the chain of custody, and send the final report to the Audit Committee.
Written as general textile practice and reviewed by four independent AI models. Not yet signed off by a human subject-matter expert. Upload your own SOPs and standards, and every answer shows which source it used.
Ten questions it ships with
The template’s starter questions. Your team can edit them, or ask in its own words.
What a working paper recorded
What did the working paper for this audit record — scope, sample, testing performed and conclusion?
Controls that tested ineffective
Which controls in the control matrix tested as ineffective, what exceptions were found, and how many?
Surprise stock check results
What did the last surprise stock check find, and how were the variances explained?
Open findings and remediation
Which audit findings are still open, what does each require, and where does the remediation stand?
What an investigation concluded
What did this investigation conclude, and on what evidence? Cite the working papers.
Audit summary from the papers
Prepare an audit summary for this engagement from the working papers on record, with findings ranked by risk.
Processes not audited recently
Which processes have not been audited in the last cycle, and when was each last covered?
Repeat findings across cycles
Which findings have repeated across audit cycles, and what does the record say about why they recurred?
Exceptions by process this quarter
Show exceptions raised this quarter by process, and tell me where they concentrate.
Status of the audit plan
Where does the annual audit plan stand — completed, in progress, and not yet started — against the calendar?
Internal Audit & Risk: questions before a demo
Our stock registers and signed count sheets are on paper. Can it still help?
Only with what exists as text. A scanned count sheet or a photographed bin card has no text to read, and Mavick does not read text from images. Type the count into an Excel or CSV file with book and counted quantity, shortage and excess quantity, and shortage value and excess value, each in its own column, then upload it to Internal Audit. The agent totals the shortage value for a bin or category you name from the rows. The book side comes from the system stock report: export it and put book and counted quantity in the same file, since the agent does not join two files.
Can it run continuous monitoring on our stores and purchase data?
No. Nothing runs between questions and nothing watches the ERP: it answers when someone on the audit team asks. What it does is count, not test. Across one export of up to 5,000 rows (split a larger year by quarter), it counts or sums the POs to one vendor, the scrap sold in one month or the write-offs one approver signed, filtered on exact values in your columns, with the rows cited. It does not match POs to GRNs across files or pick out unusual entries by itself. If you export GRN and issue dates for the quarter, it can count the GRNs your sheet marks as posted late.
Will Stores or Sourcing see our investigation files?
No. Files uploaded to Internal Audit stay inside it. Other departments’ agents cannot read them, and their people work in their own workspace; that separation is built into how Mavick stores and retrieves everything. Keep investigation files out of the factory-wide shared documents, which every department can read. The boundary also runs the other way: the audit agent cannot open Stores’ or Sourcing’s own uploads, so upload what an audit needs, such as the system stock report or a PO export, to Internal Audit.
Can it see vendor bank accounts for a duplicate or fake vendor test?
Not from the ERP. The audit agent reads no vendor records there, only Odoo invoices, and salary, bank-account and tax-ID fields are removed from ERP records before the agent reads them. If a test needs those fields, upload a vendor-master export to Internal Audit, where it stays. Name an account number and the agent counts the vendor rows that carry it, citing them. It does not search the file for shared accounts by itself.
Will the agent rate a finding or write the audit conclusion?
No. Findings, ratings, test results and conclusions come from your working papers and tracker, never from the agent. Any exception count or variance total it gives is counted from the rows of a table you uploaded, with the rows cited, never estimated. It quotes the rating each finding carries, orders a summary by those ratings, and says so where a finding has none. Asked what an investigation concluded, it quotes the report and the evidence it cites, and adds no allegation of its own. The judgement stays with your auditors.
Can it keep our risk register up to date?
It reads the register you upload to Internal Audit: each risk, its owner, the mitigation and the residual rating. Ask which risks carry a High residual rating, and it counts them from the rows and quotes each one’s owner and mitigation, citing the rows. It does not score a risk or change a rating; ratings come from your register. It can draft the email asking an owner for an update, which an admin approves or declines, and it runs only if approved. Each approve or decline is recorded in Mavick’s audit trail with who decided.
Bring Internal Audit & Risk. We’ll build it on the call.
Book a 30-minute demo (opens in a new tab)- support@mavick.si
- Demo calendar
- calendly.com/safock/30min (opens in a new tab)