Where margin slips between the quote and the shipment
Each one starts in a file the costing desk already keeps: a merchandiser’s cost sheet, the yarn model, the buyer’s target-price email, the post-cost nobody finished. The cost shows up as lost margin, after the order has shipped.
Every merchandiser keeps a cost sheet, and no two use the same rates
Each style is costed in its own Excel file, copied from the last one. Fabric rate, consumption, wastage %, CMT and overhead ratio drift from file to file. When the buyer asks for a repeat, nobody can say which yarn rate or incoterm the FOB was built on. ITC’s costing guide says most cost-sheet errors are incremental: a button price or a few minutes. The serious problems come from a cost left out of the sheet.
14%
Among suppliers in an ILO global survey (1,454 respondents, 2016) who had accepted orders below production cost, the share who said this was at least sometimes due to their own costing mistakes. All sectors.
Source: International Labour Organization (ILO), INWORK Issue Brief No.10: Purchasing practices and working conditions in global supply chains: Global Survey results (opens in a new tab), 2017.
The post-cost comes months late, or never
The pre-cost assumed a consumption, a wastage %, a line efficiency and an overhead rate. Then the marker uses more fabric than costed, the line runs below plan, or the order lands in a slow month. If the post-cost waits for months, nobody can trace the loss to a line item, and the next quote repeats the same rates. The playbook says a post-cost not done within 30 days of shipment “becomes archaeology”.
$1.86 to $2.23
Overhead per unit in ITC’s worked job-costing example: the cost sheet assumed $1.86, but the order ran in a slow period, with total orders below capacity. A teaching example, not survey data.
Source: International Trade Centre (ITC), The Garment Costing Guide: for small firms in value chains (opens in a new tab), 2022.
Cotton moves while the quote is still open
The playbook calls yarn cost the largest variable. Yet the yarn model carries whatever cotton rate was typed last, the FX rate is weeks old, and nobody checks the quote’s validity date before the buyer confirms. Export prices are often fixed months ahead, so when yarn rises the mill pays the difference. The costing manager and the CFO see it at post-cost.
60%
Rise in cotton yarn prices in India, from Rs 250 per kg in early 2026 to around Rs 400 by September 2026. Tiruppur exporters estimate production costs up by as much as 15%, according to a consultant quoted by KNN India.
Source: KNN India, Cotton Yarn Prices Surge 60% To Rs 400/Kg, Threaten Textile Export Competitiveness (opens in a new tab), 2026.
A target FOB below cost, and the buyer wants an answer now
The buyer sends a target price with a deadline: meet it or lose the order. The costing desk has to show where the gap sits (fabric, trims, CMT, overhead or margin), which levers are real and where the margin floor is. When the answer is worked out in a hurry from someone else’s sheet, the mill can accept a price it loses money on. The CFO sees the numbers only after the buyer has the price.
52.1%
Share of buyers who used “take it or leave it” (meet the target cost or lose the order), as rated by suppliers worldwide in Better Buying’s 2024 index. Only 48.9% of suppliers said all orders were priced for compliant production.
Source: Better Buying Institute (Cascale), Suppliers’ Perspectives on Solutions for Better Costing (opens in a new tab), 2025.
Quotes, post-costs and the yarn model, read line by line
It answers from your costing sheets, BOMs, yarn cost model and quote register, and shows the file and rows behind every number. Any email, Slack message or quote-register row it prepares waits for an admin to approve or decline it, and runs only if approved.
What any quote was built on, read from its costing sheet
Reads your documents
Upload costing sheets and quote emails to Costing. Ask what a quote was based on and the agent lists the fabric rate, consumption, wastage %, trims, CMT, overhead ratio, margin and incoterm, citing the file and rows. A line the sheet lacks is named as missing, not filled in. If two sheets exist for one style, it sets them side by side with the dates they record, and leaves your team to choose the current one.
Ask“What was our FOB for style P-2210 built on? Give the fabric rate, consumption, wastage, CMT, overhead and incoterm.”
Pre-cost against post-cost, head by head, from your rows
Answers with sources
Upload an order’s pre-cost and post-cost as two CSV or Excel files, each with a cost-head column. The agent sums fabric, trims, CMT and overhead in each file from the rows, sets each pair side by side with the difference, marks any head that moved more than 5% and cites the rows. From an uploaded quote register it counts or averages too, such as one buyer’s average quoted CMT in a season.
Ask“Set the pre-cost against the post-cost for order 5531: fabric, trims, CMT and overhead, each with the difference and the rows you used.”
The margin variance summary, as a sheet you can send on
Creates files
For a shipped order, the agent builds a sheet with each cost head’s pre-cost and post-cost total, both calculated from the rows, with the difference, the variance % and the rows behind each. It notes where the playbook says to look first: cotton or shrinkage for fabric, a substitution for trims, DHU rework or low efficiency for CMT. Ask for a change and it edits that part; every revision is kept and attributed.
Ask“Make the margin variance summary for order 5531 as a spreadsheet, with the rows behind each cost head.”
A target-price gap note, sent only if an admin approves
Acts in your tools
When a buyer’s target FOB arrives, ask the agent to set it against your full-margin quote. It reads that email in the mailbox connected to Costing, and the costing sheet, and lays the target beside the quote’s FOB and its cost heads. It writes the note to the merchandising head and CFO, for Gmail or Outlook. An admin approves or declines it; it is sent only if approved. Giving up margin is never the agent’s call.
Ask“Set this buyer’s target FOB for style K-118 against our full-margin quote by cost head, and write a note to the merchandising head and CFO.”
The cotton, FX and conversion rates behind the yarn model
Answers with sources
Ask which cotton rate, FX rate and spinning conversion cost the current yarn model uses, and the date it records. The agent answers from the uploaded model or your connected Google Sheet and points to the rows or cells. It has no cotton market feed: the spot rate is the one your team records. From the quote register, it reads out the open quotes it finds for a buyer, with their cotton basis and validity date.
Ask“Which cotton rate and FX rate does the current yarn model use, and when was it last updated? List this buyer’s open quotes with their validity dates.”
A repeat order, a 30-day post-cost and a target FOB under the quote
A repeat order, costed by someone who has left
Costing executive
A buyer asks to repeat last season’s style at the same FOB, and the merchandiser who costed it has left.
Asks
“What was the FOB for style P-2210 built on last season? Give each line, and compare its yarn rate with today’s yarn model.”
The agent
Reads the costing sheet and the quote email uploaded to Costing. Lists the fabric rate, consumption, wastage %, trims, CMT, overhead ratio, margin and incoterm, citing the file and rows for each, and names any line the sheet does not show. Sets the sheet’s yarn rate beside the current yarn cost model’s, with the date of each.
Result
The re-costing starts from a known basis, and the yarn line that has moved since last season is visible before the new price is quoted.
Closing the post-cost inside 30 days
Costing manager
An order shipped three weeks ago. The playbook wants its post-cost within 30 days, and the post-cost sheet is now filled in.
Asks
“Make the variance summary for order 5531: pre-cost against post-cost by cost head, with the difference and the rows behind each.”
The agent
Reads the pre-cost and post-cost files uploaded to Costing. Sums fabric, trims, CMT and overhead in each file from the rows, sets each pair side by side with the difference and variance %, and marks any head past the playbook’s 5% line for a root-cause review. Builds the summary as a spreadsheet, citing the rows behind each total.
Result
Each head’s variance is worked out from the rows while the order is still fresh, and the heads past 5% are named, ready for a root-cause review with the function that owns each.
A target FOB below the full-margin quote
Costing executive
The buyer emails a target FOB for a knit top that sits below our full-margin quote, with three days to answer.
Asks
“Set the buyer’s target FOB for style K-118 against our full-margin quote by cost head, and write a note to the merchandising head and CFO.”
The agent
Reads the buyer’s email in the mailbox connected to Costing, the costing sheet and the buyer’s margin policy. Lays the target beside the quote’s FOB and each cost head, with the margin the sheet records and the policy floor, and lists the levers the playbook names: yarn substitution, local trims, marker re-engineering, or less margin for volume or a strategic buyer. Writes the note to go out as an Outlook email.
Approval
The note waits for the costing manager, as department admin, to approve or decline. Nothing is sent unless it is approved, and the audit trail keeps the decision and who made it.
Result
If approved, the note is sent to the merchandising head and CFO with the gap by cost head and the levers. A margin below the floor stays a decision for Costing, Sales and the CFO.
Margin at risk in a missed cost line, a cotton move or a buyer’s target
These are published figures on garment costing and cotton prices, plus two worked examples from ITC’s costing guide, each cited at its source. None is a Mavick result. A pilot records your own variance, quote-to-PO and margin figures, then measures them again.
Quotes checked for missing cost lines before they go out
10%
In ITC’s basic cost sheet, fabric at $3.50 a metre instead of $3.00 moves the FOB from $10 to $11, a 10% change, while the example’s net profit is only 5% of FOB. A teaching illustration.
How the agent helps
Before quoting, ask the agent to read the costing sheet against the playbook’s pre-quote checklist: BOM complete, yarn model run, CMT from SMV and wage, overhead ratio, margin per buyer policy, sensitivity table, validity stated. It names the items it does not find in the sheet, and the date the sheet records for each rate. Whether a rate is still current is your team’s call.
Track: Pre-vs-post variance %, by order
Source: International Trade Centre (ITC), The Garment Costing Guide: for small firms in value chains (opens in a new tab), 2022.
Yarn rates checked before the buyer confirms
14.9%
Fall in the US producer price index for raw cotton in one month, May 2019, when US–China trade talks broke down. The source calls cotton a volatile market where price spikes and drops are prevalent. A US index, shown only for scale.
How the agent helps
The agent says which cotton rate, FX rate and conversion cost the yarn model uses, and the date it records. From your quote register it reads out the open quotes it finds for a buyer, with their cotton basis and validity date, so your team can re-cost a stale quote before it becomes a PO. It does not forecast cotton or FX.
Track: Yarn cost-model accuracy against actual yarn PO cost
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, International cotton trade and causes of price volatility in the United States (opens in a new tab), 2020.
Target-price answers backed by the cost sheet
52%
Share of textile and clothing suppliers in an ILO global survey who had accepted orders, in the past year, at prices that did not cover their production costs. Across all sectors the share was 39%. Survey of 1,454 suppliers, 2016.
How the agent helps
The agent lays a buyer’s target FOB beside your full-margin quote and each cost head behind it, with the margin against your policy floor, and writes the gap note. Any email it prepares waits for an admin to approve or decline, and goes out only if approved. The playbook’s rule holds: tell Merchandising the gap, never absorb it silently.
Track: Margin %, by buyer
Source: International Labour Organization (ILO), INWORK Issue Brief No.10: Purchasing practices and working conditions in global supply chains: Global Survey results (opens in a new tab), 2017.
What to baseline before a pilot
Measure each one before the pilot starts, then again at its end.
| KPI to baseline | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Pre-vs-post variance %, by order | The playbook targets ±2%. Over 5% calls for a root-cause review with the function responsible. Over 10% on one order goes to the costing manager, CFO and plant head, with the root cause due within a week. |
| Quote-to-PO conversion rate, by buyer | Tracked buyer by buyer. The playbook reads a low rate as quotes set too high, or a buyer who is only gathering data. |
| Margin %, by buyer | The playbook expects buyer pressure to push it down unless the price is renegotiated. A demand below the policy floor goes to Costing, Sales and the CFO. |
| Yarn cost-model accuracy against actual yarn PO cost | The playbook targets ±2% and re-checks the model weekly against actual yarn POs. Those prices are Sourcing & Procurement’s records: keep them in your yarn model sheet or upload a yarn PO list to Costing. |
| Shipped orders post-costed within 30 days | Not one of the playbook’s four KPIs but its working rhythm: a post-cost done more than 30 days after shipment is too late to trace the loss to a line item. |
What the agent works from
Records it reads
- Costing sheet
- BOM
- Yarn cost model
- FOB quote
- Pre-vs-post variance report
- Sensitivity table
- Tech pack
- Quote register
In your ERP
From the factory’s ERP connection, the costing agent reads Odoo invoices only: number, customer, total, status and date, each with the time fetched. It writes nothing to any ERP. Cost sheets, BOMs, the yarn model, the quote register and yarn prices paid come from uploaded Excel or CSV files or a Google Sheet. The demo shows whether your invoices sit in Odoo.
One ERP connection serves the whole factory: SAP Business One, SAP S/4HANA, Odoo, Oracle NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, WFX Cloud ERP or Datatex NOW. This agent reads only the records named above; we check yours on the call.
In your tools
When you ask, reads a buyer’s target-price email in the Gmail or Outlook mailbox connected to Costing, or the quote register in Google Sheets. Prepares the gap note or variance email for Gmail or Outlook, a new quote-register row, or a re-quote notice for your team in Slack. An admin approves or declines each one; it runs only if approved.
Tools named today: Gmail, Outlook, Google Sheets, Slack and WhatsApp Business.
Never made up
- Cost figures, rates or overhead absorption assumptions
- BOM consumption quantities or wastage percentages
- Quoted prices and incoterm bases
- Margin percentages and realised profitability
If it is not in your connected data, the agent says so.
Belongs to another department
- Actual material purchase pricesSourcing & Procurement
- Booked costs and accounting treatmentFinance & Accounts
- Buyer negotiation and order confirmationMerchandising
- Actual fabric consumption in the cutting room and on the linesGarmenting & Stitching
- Actual greige-to-finished yield through dyeingDyeing & Processing
What the Costing & Pricing playbook covers
SOP: pre-costing an inquiry
Start from the tech pack, target FOB and volume. Build the BOM with wastage. Cost fabric from yarn (cotton spot plus spinning) through knitting or weaving, processing and finishing, at a greige-to-finished realisation of typically 88–95%. Trims at the vendor’s latest price, CMT as SMV × wage plus line overhead, overhead by ratio, margin per buyer policy. Then FOB, CIF or EXW.
Decision rule: cotton moves over 3% while a quote is valid
If you hold the quote, you absorb the margin shift. Honour it within validity and re-quote outside it, at the current cotton spot. If the buyer presses, offer a yarn-locked deal: the mill fixes yarn now and the buyer confirms within 7 days. Quotes run 7–30 days, depending on how volatile cotton is.
KPI: yarn cost-model accuracy
The model’s output against the actual yarn PO cost, with a target of ±2%. The chain runs from cotton spot through spinning conversion cost to yarn FOB. The playbook re-validates it weekly against actual yarn POs and calls a weekly refresh non-negotiable.
Edge case: the buyer asks for the sensitivity table
Each quote carries a sensitivity table: cotton ±5%, FX ±2%, conversion cost ±3%. The playbook keeps it for internal use and shares it with a buyer only inside a negotiation. Outside one, the table gets used as a baseline cap on price.
Written as general textile practice and reviewed by four independent AI models. Not yet signed off by a human subject-matter expert. Upload your own SOPs and standards, and every answer shows which source it used.
Ten questions it ships with
The template’s starter questions. Your team can edit them, or ask in its own words.
Cost build-up for a style
Show the full cost build-up on record for this style — fabric, trims, CMT, overhead and margin — with the assumptions behind each line.
Pre-costing versus post-costing
Compare the pre-costing with the post-costing for this completed order and explain where the margin moved.
BOM consumption against actual
What does the BOM assume this style consumes, and what did it actually consume? Show the variance by component.
What a quote was based on
What was our FOB quote for this style based on — which rates, which consumption, and which incoterm?
Impact of a yarn price move
If yarn prices move by a given percentage, how does that flow through to this style’s cost and margin? Show the calculation.
Margin variance summary
Prepare a margin variance summary for this order from the costing sheets on record, showing which cost heads drove the difference.
Lowest-margin orders this quarter
Which orders delivered this quarter had the lowest realised margin, and what do the post-costings attribute it to?
Overhead absorption assumptions
What overhead absorption rate are we using in current costings, and what is it based on? Cite the source.
Compare two styles’ costs
Compare the cost build-ups of these two styles line by line and tell me where the difference actually comes from.
Wastage assumptions in use
What wastage percentages are we assuming in costing for this process, and how do they compare with actual wastage recorded?
Costing & Pricing: questions before a demo
Can the agent change prices or cost rates in our ERP?
No. Mavick writes no prices, costs or rates to any ERP, and the costing agent writes nothing to one at all. From the ERP it reads only Odoo invoices, where you run Odoo. Your costing sheets stay exactly as uploaded: when a rate changes, your team updates the sheet and uploads the new file.
Each merchandiser keeps a costing sheet in Excel. Can the agent work from them?
Yes, once they are uploaded to the Costing department, up to 10 MB a file. Every sheet of a workbook is searchable. The first sheet is the table the agent sums and counts from, up to 5,000 rows, so keep the cost lines there. It names the file it read. It does not merge the files or decide which version is current: your team does, and uploads the new file when rates change. A scanned, signed cost sheet has no text to read.
Will Merchandising or the production floor see our margins?
No. Cost sheets, the margin policy and buyer-wise rates uploaded to Costing stay inside Costing: other departments’ agents cannot read them, and people in other departments see only their own workspace. That boundary is built into how Mavick stores and retrieves everything, not a setting someone can forget. A file is seen beyond Costing only if someone shares it across the factory. The same wall means the costing agent cannot open the cutting room’s reports: for actual consumption, upload them to Costing.
Can it re-cost an open quote when the yarn rate in our model changes?
No, the re-cost is your team’s. What the agent does is find the quotes to look at. After a yarn-model update, ask for a buyer’s open quotes and it reads out the ones it finds in your quote register, with the cotton basis and validity date each records, beside the cotton rate and date the current model carries, citing the rows. The playbook honours a quote within validity and re-quotes outside it. Mavick has no market price feed and does not forecast cotton, yarn or FX: every rate is one your team records. If a quote carries a sensitivity table, the agent reads it and cites it, but builds no new price scenarios.
Can it check our BOM and yarn model against what was actually used and paid?
Only from records connected to Costing. Upload the cutting report or consumption sheet for an order, and the agent sets actual consumption beside the BOM by component, citing the rows. If your yarn model sheet or an uploaded yarn PO list carries the price paid, it sets that beside the model’s rate for each count. If the actual figure is not there, it says so. Actual consumption belongs to Garmenting & Stitching, greige-to-finished yield to Dyeing & Processing, and purchase prices to Sourcing & Procurement.
Can it work out our overhead rate or cost per minute from the books?
No. No ERP connection gives Mavick the general ledger or payroll. The overhead ratio and cost per minute come from your own overhead and CPM calculation: upload that file, and the agent quotes the rate, what it is based on and the file it came from. After a wage change, ask how many quotes in the quote register you uploaded still use the old cost per minute, and it counts them from the rows. Booked costs and their accounting treatment belong to Finance & Accounts.
Bring Costing & Pricing. We’ll build it on the call.
Book a 30-minute demo (opens in a new tab)- support@mavick.si
- Demo calendar
- calendly.com/safock/30min (opens in a new tab)